Contents
Are Electric Vehicle Fires a Major Concern? New Data Debunks the Myth
For years, a persistent myth has circulated: electric vehicles (EVs) are prone to catching fire more often than their gasoline counterparts. However, a recent comprehensive report based on data from the past year provides compelling evidence to the contrary, challenging common misconceptions and offering a clearer picture of EV fire safety.
The “EV Fire Safety Report,” compiled by F5A New Mobility Research & Consulting in collaboration with the Polish Association for New Mobility (PSNM) and the State Fire Service, reveals crucial insights into the frequency of EV fires compared to internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles.
EV Fires vs. Gasoline Cars: The Numbers Don’t Lie
One of the most significant findings from the report directly addresses the public’s perception of EV fire risk. The data unequivocally shows that electric vehicles are involved in a remarkably small percentage of all car fires:
- Electric vehicle fires account for a mere 0.45% of all vehicle fire incidents.
- In stark contrast, internal combustion engine vehicles (powered by gasoline, diesel, or LPG) are responsible for a staggering 98.45% of all vehicle fires.
To put this into concrete figures, the report recorded 9,515 fires involving ICE vehicles, compared to just 44 incidents involving electric vehicles. Furthermore, the fire incident rate per 1,000 vehicles is notably lower for electric cars, indicating a reduced risk of ignition compared to traditional gasoline-powered vehicles.
This statistical evidence suggests that the perceived higher risk of EV fires is, in fact, a widespread misconception. The data clearly demonstrates that EVs are statistically less likely to catch fire than vehicles with internal combustion engines.
Improved Emergency Response: Faster Intervention Times
Beyond the statistics on fire frequency, the report also highlighted significant advancements in emergency response for EV incidents. Last year, the average intervention time for fire brigades dealing with burning electric vehicles saw a considerable reduction:
- Average intervention time decreased from 4 hours and 21 minutes to 2 hours and 40 minutes.
This improvement reflects increased training, better equipment, and evolving protocols for handling EV-specific fire challenges, contributing to safer outcomes and minimizing potential damage.
Key Incidents and Evolving Safety Protocols
The past year also presented notable learning experiences:
- In August, the first recorded electric vehicle fire in an underground garage occurred. Such incidents are critical for developing specific safety guidelines and emergency procedures for complex environments.
- Notably, the report also highlighted the first recorded ignition of a hydrogen-powered vehicle – specifically a bus – underscoring the ongoing need for research and safety protocols across all emerging vehicle technologies.
Expert Insight: A Global Trend Towards Lower Concern
Albert Kania from F5A New Mobility Research & Consulting emphasized that the declining trend in EV fires is consistent with observations from other nations that adopted electromobility earlier.
“In markets that embraced electromobility sooner and faster, like Norway, a consistent pattern has long been observed: the more electric cars on the roads, the less emotion surrounds fires, because the numbers confirm they do not pose a greater risk,” Kania stated.
This expert perspective reinforces the report’s findings, suggesting that as EV adoption grows and experience accumulates, the concerns surrounding their fire safety naturally diminish, replaced by data-driven understanding.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Are electric cars more likely to catch fire than gasoline cars?
A: No, recent data indicates that electric vehicles are statistically less likely to catch fire than gasoline or diesel vehicles. EV fires accounted for only 0.45% of all vehicle fires in the latest report, compared to 98.45% for internal combustion engine vehicles.
Q: How long does it take for firefighters to extinguish an EV fire?
A: According to the latest data, the average intervention time for electric vehicle fires has significantly decreased from over 4 hours to approximately 2 hours and 40 minutes, thanks to improved training and equipment for emergency services.
Q: What contributes to the lower fire risk of electric vehicles?
A: While the report highlights statistical frequency, factors contributing to lower fire risk can include fewer flammable liquids and complex mechanical systems compared to ICE vehicles. Modern EV battery management systems also incorporate advanced safety features designed to prevent thermal runaway.
Source: F5A New Mobility Research & Consulting, Polish Association for New Mobility (PSNM), and State Fire Service.
About Post Author
